Twitter Facebook LinkedIn Contact Us RSS Feeds          
CALL US: : 604-681-1310
Articles, Civil Litigation, Default Judgments, John Bilawich, Jonathan J. Weisman, Latest News, Robert Holmes, Terrence King

Successful Appeal in Kilderry v Addwest


Does B.C. have jurisdiction over a dispute involving an investment by foreign parties in a foreign mine where the only connections to B.C. are that one of parties previously lived here and a corporation added to the case is the ultimate parent of the company that owned the mine?

On February 25, 2013, the BC Court of Appeal allowed the appeal with costs throughout in Kilderry Holdings Ltd. v. Addwest Minerals, Inc. et al, 2013 BCCA 82.  Robert D. Holmes, Q.C. was successful counsel for the Appellants.  The case involved overlapping and complex issues of court jurisdiction, shareholder rights and corporate law.

The Plaintiff claimed it had made loans and sought judgment for that and damages for an alleged bargain for bonus shares, all relating to a gold mine in Arizona.  Initially, none of the parties were within British Columbia.  At the trial court level, the Plaintiff applied to add a BC company related to some of the foreign parties in order to bolster its arguments for jurisdiction.

On appeal, the court held that insufficient and ruled that BC did not have territorial jurisdiction over the dispute.  The court added that the claims for damages only afforded a claim to the company in which the Plaintiff alleged it was a shareholder, not the Plaintiff itself.

Share on Facebook

Comments are closed.

Latest Posts


1300-1111 West Georgia Street
Vancouver BC V6E 4M3 Canada
Phone: (604) 681-1310
Fax: (604) 681-1307


Important: This website is operated and maintained by Holmes and Bilawich and contains information and hypertext links to information of interest to Holmes and Bilawich, our clients and the general public

No lawyer/client relationship is created unless and until we expressly agree and mutually satisfactory arrangements for our retainer are made.